The J. Peterman Company Avis 

Just be sure that if you are due a refund that you start with “I’ll be looking into taking legal action”. After 3 months of being reasonable, that’s what it took.

I really would not even give them one star, is there a minus minus minus star? Their refunds are REDICULOUS, quite honestly I think they are on the brink of being a SCAM! They might even be on the brink of closing down, they do not have the money for refunds TERRIBLE! They say they are trying to organize their company don't believe them, don't make that purchase, you will be sorry!

Buyer beware. I have been ordering off and on from them for years and their sizes have always been on point. I ordered the party of the season dress for a wedding and checked their size chart. Felt confident ordering the small 4-6. The dress arrived marked small and does not match their size chart. Easily an 8-10. Despite this being a quality control issue on their part, I was denied an exchange for an extra small because the dress was final sale. I understand if this was buyer's remorse but their sizing is wrong by their own size chart! Shout out to Michelle who tried to help me but management would not give her the approval. I am stuck with a dress that will cost at least a hundred bucks to take apart and alter. Plus I have to find another dress for the wedding. Congrats management! You saved on shipping that I probably would have had to pay myself but you have lost a long time customer. I will never order from this company again.
Most, if not all, of their items are made in China anyway. Probably in sweat shops that abuse workers since they don't care about you as a customer at all. I have unsubscribed from their email list. I would give them zero stars if I could since the dress was not cheap even on sale. Horrible!

If I could give J Peterman a zero rating, I would. Around March 6th, almost four months ago, I returned an item. I have yet to get my refund! A dispute with my bank is pending. BUYER DEFINITELY BEWARE! I received all kinds of double talk from them about my refund. Unless you know you will not have to make a return, do not make a purchase. Better yet, just do not buy from them.

We have ordered from this company for years. This is the second time we sent something back. Both times, getting a refund was nearly impossible. We returned our items in March. The story changed each time we called. Finally, in May, we contacted our bank’s credit card folks. Amazing! They said we could leave it with them; and, issued us a credit for the full amount. No more shopping with Peterman!

Sad to see a once great company reduced to substandard quality. The catalog is still enticing, but the products no longer live up to the billing they get, as they once did.

0 stars really. I’ve been waiting and calling regularly for a refund - over 2 months now! I get the feeling that they are going to declare bankruptcy, so if they stall long enough, they’ll never have to refund my money.

0 Stars actually!!!!!! I’ve ordered from this company for several years. The quality was good. I ordered a sweater for my husband in December- Christmas present, and by mid January it was balling up terribly. I called customer service and was told to it. I tracked and the item was back in their warehouse by the end of that month. Since, I’ve been following up regularly. I’ve been promised over and over again that I will receive my money- It’s been almost 4 months!

Ordered an item from most recent catalog on 3/24/25. By 4/ 7 I still had no notification of shipment. Called them and was told the item was backordered. How can a brand new item in a brand new catalog be backordered?? Was told it would be in by 4/24. Today is 5/2 still no item, no notification. Called again and now they have no idea when or if the item will be available. WHY ADVERTISE AN ITEM IF YOU CANNOT GUARANTEE THAT IT IS AVAILABLE???????? Not just poor customer service and business operation but underhanded.

Buyer Beware! If I could give a lower rating for this company I wouldn"t hesitate. I have been a customer with this company since the 90's and I have always loved the product and customer service. What happened? Customer service is terrible. The left hand does not have a clue what the right hand is doing. I placed an order for an item on March 15,2025 in the amount of $178 and received notification that my order had been received and I would receive notification as soon as my package has shipped, money was immediately charged to my account which I thought was odd, generally this doesn't happen until product is shipped on 03/17/2025 I received notification that order has been shipped and was on its way within 4-7 days with tracking my package # I waited until 03/21/2025 and carrier ups does not have possession of my package on March 27 I contacted customer service and was told they would follow up and get back with me soon I was never contacted so I called again on March 28 to follow up and was told they were researching the matter and wuld get back with me as soon as possible I was never contacted on April 4 I contacted my credit card company and disputed the charge because I have never received my order I received txt today April 16 saying they did know there was an issue until they received my chargeback needless to say I am properly disappointed.

On April 1, I had an appointment scheduled for a clogged drain. When I called to cancel they suggested I get my electrical panel looked at. I agreed due to our electrical bills being over $100 higher than usual. Their salesman said it was being caused by electrical panel and it would need to be replaced. He also stressed how we were at risk of a house fire if it wasn't replaced immediately. We agreed to have it replaces but found out later that day, that it wasn't the electrical panel that needed to be replaced, but it was due to a repair that Aron from Peterman Brothers didn't do correctly on 12/27. We looked at our energy bill and realized the higher energy bill started right after his "repair". We found out he wired it incorrectly and connected our furnace to run of emergency heat. We also were told that there was no danger of fire as well. We immediately texted, called, sent a message through chat and sent an email canceling the order. The loan company canceled the loan, but now Peterman said they need to keep $250 from my deposit. There was no mention of this with signing up and they made no attempt to correct their error from December after finding out their guy didn't do his job the first time. This whole experience has been a nightmare and we just want our money back from these con men

If I could rate no stars I would.

Do not do business with this compony.

2 Christmas orders returned for fit and acknowledged received (about $500). 5 phone calls to see why credit not yet received. Now April and still the same nonsense - should get in 10 to 14 days. My opinion - unethical. Buy elsewhere!!

I returned an item of $161 in a timely manner. 3 phone calls and 4 emails since January 9th and still no refund. I have purchased several items in the past and was happy with high quality items. Don't they want my business?

Linda Beney

J Peterman has not refunded my money two months after I returned my item, which cost $249. I have emailed and chatted with numerous people and/or bots to no avail, all with bogus excuses. I will never buy anything from them again. They have not been vetted by Better Business Bureau either. Used to be a decent company though it did go bankrupt in the 90s. Bottom of the barrel now.

I too have yet to receive my refund. Their customer service acknowledges that they received my return at least 6 weeks ago. I too have to pay a return fee. I’ll never do business with them again.

To be honest, I would have given 0 stars if that was an option, but will afford one star because of their catalog. For an institution with such uniqueness, history, and style - - not to mention the cost of the merchandise - - they do a HORRIBLE job with respect to returns.
Almost three months ago I purchased well over $1,000 of garments (which isn't saying much giving the cost of each item), and unfortunately ended up having to return half of them. I am going on my 8th week of no refund, no communications except those intiated on my end, and being told by the customer service rep that they themselves will personally handle my refund and get back to me, only to have to call back multiple days later due to no communcation nor refund in my bank account.
Aside the cost of the items, you are also charged ~$25 to have the items shipped back. So, in addition to the total amount of the merchandise, the cost to ship, as well as the interest accrued daily on my credit card because the full balance of the purchase remains, I can honestly say what started off as an exciting first J. Peterman experience, has ended sadly and disappointedly being my last. I will never shop with this merchant again, nor will I encourage/support others to do the same, rather, I would discourage anyone from purchasing. Such a shame.

I purchased a watch as a Christmas gift back in November 2024. I needed to return the watch. Called and received my RMA#. They received the watch on January 9, 2025. To this date, I still have not received my credit. I have called numerous times and was told due to large returns from the Christmas season, they are behind. To this date, March 20, 2025, I still have not received my credit. I will never order from them again.

It's a shame... I've been a customer since the 90s. This has always been such a fun catalog and a great customer experience. Now it's like pulling teeth to get one's order. I cancelled the last order I made a few months ago and gave them a last chance, for old time's sake... I'm going around and around customer service at the moment and will likely end up having to cancel via my credit card company. It's so sad to see the slow, painful customer service death of this company.

Ordered (4) items (Qty 2 French Terry Bomber Cardigans, Cabana Shirt, and Linen Safari Jacket) via a promo email (30% off and free shipping) on my mobile phone. Order #W210432. (3) items shipped/ arrived and 4th/ Linen Safari Jacket shows pending. Also, my fault for not noticing the itemization so I was charged the shipping. 1st attempt: Emailed to address both issues. Customer Service responded indicating the item was on back-order (but it was for the wrong item/ a Short Sleeve A-list Pocket Crew/ Size Med) and didn't address the shipping. I responded/ noted the corrections. They auto-closed the ticket. 2nd attempt: Emailed to address both issues. Customer Service responded indicating "a refund for the free ground shipping applied to your order as per the Black Friday promotion" and 4th item is on back-order. Confused by the shipping comment, I responded with screenshots showing I was charged shipping/ so not applied to the order and I don't have a refund on my credit card statement and the Linen Safari Jacket is in stock per their website (shows Qty9 available in my size). 3rd attempt/ concurrent with the 2nd attempt reply: I went to their website and completed a form to address both issues and am waiting for their reply. I am hopeful both responses will be free of erroneous information. Seems like competent Customer Service should be table stakes for an online retailer, but here we are...

The Thug Cap description says
"made in Ireland". The sewn-in label on the inside of the Cap says "Made in Poland". I noted this on the email follow-up from their Reseach form. No answer from Peterman received. Surely they know where their products are made. Why lie about it? Why no answer from them?