Marketed as hotel quality; we found mold, stains and damage in nearly every room
Pied A Terre Paris presents its apartments as design-led residences, and the listing for the Arts et Métiers Superior Two Bedroom apartment promises "hotel-quality bedding, linens & towels." We booked it for a family of four from October 29 to November 2, choosing it because the floor plan on the company's website shows two bathrooms, each with a toilet and shower.
In our experience, after many stays in hotels and short-term rentals, this apartment had the most serious hygiene problems we have encountered.
Check-in was confirmed for 4:00 PM. When we arrived at 4:55 PM, the apartment was still being cleaned. Once inside, this is what we found and photographed:
In the main bathroom, black mold ran along the entire bottom hem of the shower curtain, with rust-colored stains above it. Lifting the toilet seat revealed a thick brown band of limescale and staining under the rim. The vanity countertop had peeled away, leaving the bare board underneath exposed. The shower head was crusted with limescale, and the grout around the drain was worn and stained. There was no toilet paper.
In the second bathroom, the shower curtain hem was also stained, and there was more buildup under the toilet rim. On the laundry shelf, bed linens had been left crumpled.
In the second bedroom, the glass desktop was cracked across its surface, with a large stain spreading underneath the glass and dark residue along its edge. The cracks left sharp edges, which made the desk unsafe to use; resting a hand or arm on it carried a real risk of being cut. The bed skirt had a visible stain line.
In the kitchen and dining area, the chair seats were stained and the glass dining table top showed water damage underneath. Paint was chipped on the dining room wall, blistering and peeling on the living room wall, and the plaster was cracked beside the entrance door.
In our view, the apartment was far from the condition shown in the company's photos.
We reported the mold, the damaged countertop, the cracked glass as a safety hazard, and the missing toilet paper to the company by email that afternoon, with photos. A housekeeper arrived more than an hour after our first report. Our refund request was declined. The company offered to move us to its Oberkampf Superior Loft, which it described as an upgrade, and we accepted. We arrived there at 8:39 PM, more than four and a half hours after the confirmed check-in time.
The Oberkampf apartment was cleaner, but it has one toilet and one shower, while both apartments are listed with 2 bathrooms; no layout information was given before the move. We also reported in writing that its shower glass was cracked, the shower door seal was coming loose, and one heated towel rail did not heat.
The company replied to emails quickly during the day.
For future guests: confirm that the apartment will be ready at check-in, and inspect and photograph every room before unpacking.
