The Dinner Detective True Crime Murder Mystery Dinner Show Avis 

it was very immersive and fun to watch!! the actors did awesome keeping us entertained and made the dinner one of a kind!!

My partner and I just attended a showing of "A Noteworthy Crime" in New Haven. It was our first Mystery Dinner theatre experience and will certainly not be our last. We found the story engaging and very humorous. The interaction of the actors with the audience kept the flow going. I particularly enjoyed having the actors embedded among the dinner guests.

Every actor performed their role beautifully. I would call them all out but that would be a bit of a spoiler. They were good at being on script and also improvising based on the reaction of the regular guests.

We were often interacting with other dinner guests to see who the suspects might be but that interaction was not entirely necessary (for those nervous about talking to random strangers). The actors are not shy to call on the guests though to introduce themselves or partake in other parts of the performance, so be prepared for that.

I found the meal quite delightful as well. I chose the Salmon. At one point, I was a little too enthralled with the puzzle that I forgot to finish my entire dessert, oh well.

Based on other reviews, we were expecting to have a great time and we did. We can't wait to see when their next script comes out!

The show was more entertaining than I expected. I went in with low expectations of the food, cast, and plot. The food was OK. Picture yourself at your cousins' wedding... that's the food.
The cast was way better than I thought they would be. The show is more "Naked Gun" than "Sherlock Holms".
The two male detectives were engaging and really worked to keep the crowd into it. They handled a little heckling fine and in good humor. The host (Carmen) was great.
The plot was just stupid. most of the room had lost interest in the actual plot and was just enjoying the drinks and cast.
So... If you had to choose between "CATS", being stabbed, or seeing this show, go to the Dinner Detective.

Awesome story, great cast! Cool experience!

Very exciting and suspenseful! So much fun. Enjoyed meeting random people.

Hilariously funny.

The Dinner Detective was a great experience for our staff! The show was enjoyed by all who attended. Steve and the rest of the Dinner Detective crew were wonderful to work with!

A very fun experience for a diverse group of people who all work together. Our usual holiday parties have been at various bars and restaurants around metro Denver, which tend to be noisy and not conducive to talking to each other. This was the perfect antidote to loud bars, we were in a very nice ballroom with elegant table settings, the actors were wonderful. Everyone had a good time.

It is a great comedic act as well as it is very interactive. Very entertaining for everyone.

So fun and interactive! Made friends!

The show was so much fun! Brought my mom, uncle and daughter and we laughed throughout. Very interactive, and involved the audience. Dinner was cold and okay, but show made up for it!

Our party of eight celebrated a birthday at the Dinner Detective I really had no expectations, which is always advisable when you don't want to be disappointed.
From what I surmise, is the Dinner Detective is a franchise that is provided murder mystery scripts from the parent company, then contracts with a hotel for room/catering, and hires local "talent". The performers were friendly, the script was "corny, and we had fun because we made it fun. It was an amateur production with the actors wearing their street clothes. No costumes or props/sets in the room just, eight round tables in a hotel event space. The food was edible, the service was poor but we didn't come to "eat" so we just accepted that part of the evening. Unfortunately three people in our party became ill about 8-9 hours later. I did voice concerns but they assured me that they did everything right (held food at right temperatures, didn't serve expired food) but did state the "protein" was cooked the day before and made a point to state the salad was made fresh that day. (this explains why you cant change what you order). While i give them credit for stating the meals were cooked the day belore, it definitely left a bad taste in my mouth.

Kuddos 10/10- The show was great! We all had a lot of fun and some great laughs. Thank you and a job well done to all. We had great team bonding.

It was an entertaining, interactive experience paired with a great meal! Definitely worth checking out!

I think the performance was amazing. The interaction with the audience made it feel better than any show before. I plan to come again when the rotate the script.

I purchased DD tickets for my sister and I for Saturday night Jan 24, 2026. I live in TN and drove to Birmingham for the show. A massive winter storm is coming as everyone in the nation knows. If I do not head home and secure my home and animals I would be stuck in AL for 4/5 days. I called to change the date for my tickets and NOPE,NO CAN DO, TO BAD was the response I got. Bad business attitude from DD. I did not ask for a refund just to change the date for my tickets. Think twice before committing to DD, you are sol if something changes.

Many facets need improvement:
1- Too much responsibility is placed on the guests to both sleuth AND mingle and not enough time to eat the courses. There is especially no time to go from the bar or restroom and arrive back in the conference room without missing something. A cash bar should be in the room where the dinner and acting takes place.
2- The wait staff did not speak English well. Plus, we had to ask for more dressing and bread and refills. There was not enough of the former to go around at a ten-person table, and they never came around unless they were waved down.
3- There should be more physical clues in the room and more scenes acted out. Insisting that each guest rely on a shared QR code in order to mine clues on their phones is time consuming - and the food is getting cold. Moreover, everyone should be given a clipboard since there is no room on the table to place or write on the single piece of paper that is the worksheet.
4- The code names are pointless and the actors think they are being creative by putting people on the spot to come up with a backstory for their code names when they are not employed actors; they are paying customers expecting to be entertained.
5- The basis of the crime is not explored at all (which revolves around the suspicious and untimely death of an actress) but we are supposed to forget about that and solve the most recent ancillary murder, which seems to ignore the overarching motive.
6 - In the end, one patron is awarded the prize for getting closer than anyone else to solving the (ancillary) murder. But the rest of the participants are not made aware of why that person won, what they uncovered, and what the rest of us may have missed. Thus, it is wholly anticlimactic.
The food, however, was very good. And it ought to be for 80 bucks a pop.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.

The entrees were horrible, the storyline was IMPOSSIBLE to follow and the "dress code" was not enforced. The seating area was too crowded. However, the dessert was delicious and parts of the show were funny.

Amazing food, a great and engaging performance with the characters, and a really interesting mystery to solve!

Great experience, very engaging with no pressure. Had a great time!!