Misleading cancellation workflow + renewal invoiced anyway
Misleading cancellation workflow + renewal invoiced anyway
We used 15Five under a self-serve/admin billing setup. The billing portal includes a “Cancel subscription” option, but when I used it, the system displayed a confirmation message saying a deactivation request had already been submitted and that someone would contact us within 24 hours to process the cancellation. We saw that same message multiple times over a period of months. No one ever contacted us within 24 hours (or at all) as the portal stated.
Despite those portal cancellation attempts, 15Five later advised they had “no record” of any prior cancellation notice and treated the subscription as auto-renewed, issuing an invoice we consider invalid. They then said cancellation could only be recognized effective a later date, which effectively forces additional billing after the point we were trying to cancel.
If your terms require written notice to a specific email address, the product should not present a “Cancel subscription” path inside the admin console that appears to accept the request and then fails to record it. If your portal says “we’ve already received your request” and “we’ll reach out within 24 hours,” customers should be able to rely on that.
Overall, this felt like a high-friction offboarding experience: a cancellation button that doesn’t reliably translate into an auditable cancellation record, followed by strict enforcement of renewal invoicing. I’d recommend getting cancellation instructions in writing from support before your renewal date and keeping screenshots of every step.





